Trucks drive up car payment costs. Some buyers pay $1,000 a month

Car shoppers are paying more than ever to finance new vehicles — and pickup trucks are driving up the average cost in at least two states, according to a report by auto site Edmunds.

During the second quarter, more than 1 in 4 vehicle shoppers in Texas and Wyoming committed to paying more than $1,000 a month, which experts say is due to the high volume of large truck purchases in those states, according to Edmunds.

More than 1 in 5 shoppers in seven other states — Colorado, Kansas, Louisiana, Montana, Nebraska, North Dakota and Utah — are also forking over more than $1,000 for their vehicles each month, Edmunds found.

More from Personal Finance:
Many borrowers may have a different student loan servicer
Here’s how to save on supplies, deal hunters say
If you found gold coins, the tax man wants a piece

The average monthly auto payment reached $733, a new record, in the second quarter of the year, according to another Edmunds report. The average monthly payment for all types of trucks was $913.

Large trucks are the third-largest vehicle sales segment in the U.S., after compact and midsize SUVs, and account for the “heaviest finger on the scale” when it comes to the average car payment, said Joseph Yoon, a consumer insights analyst for Edmunds.

“With their sales volume, it’s the trucks that are doing the most damage in terms of pushing the prices higher,” he added.

Tight inventory and sky-high prices have kept interested truck buyers on the sidelines, but as the market cools, shoppers are coming across better deals. Buyers in Texas and Wyoming, particularly, are jumping back into the market and financing $50,000 vehicles, said Tom McParland, contributing writer for automotive website Jalopnik and operator of vehicle-buying service Automatch Consulting.

Full-size pickup trucks, the segment where monthly payments can reach north of $1,000 a month for new vehicles, made up 14.5% of the total market in 2022, said auto industry analyst Paul Waatti.

“If it’s almost 15% of the market, and most are $50,000 to $60,000 as an average,” he said, “that’s going to significantly drive up the overall industry transaction price.”

Trucks have evolved from utilitarian vehicles to highly aspirational ones that consumers are willing to spend a lot of money on — and automakers are noticing, added Waatti.

A decade ago, top prices for trucks could go as high as $60,000. Nowadays, midsize trucks are soaring past that, and full-size pickups are topping out close to $100,000, he said.

“People are not using their trucks just for work anymore; they’ve become a status symbol,” Waatti said.

Texas and Wyoming are states that have always had strong demand for pickup trucks, Waatti explained.

Pickup trucks have larger fuel tanks, allowing these vehicles to have longer ranges. Many drivers in Texas and Wyoming have to navigate long, rural distances between towns or through mountains. 

Additionally, pickup trucks are beneficial for the work many people do in these areas, such as farming, ranching and energy production.

Thus, owning a pickup truck can be key in regions with lots of heavy-duty, hands-on work, Waatti said.

“They also speak to that cowboy-ish buyer,” he added.

Many ranchers and people working in oil and gas in Texas, Wyoming and similar states have more cash on hand than people in other parts of the country might expect, experts say.

“It does not seem strange to me that a quarter of the population in Texas have some serious cash” and might think, “‘I couldn’t get one of these fancy trucks before, I can get them now,'” McParland said.

“You have your average folks, and you’ve got some cowboys with cash,” he added.

Correction: Joseph Yoon is a consumer insights analyst for Edmunds. An earlier version misstated his name and title.